Comparisons

Heat pump or gas boiler: which suits your home?

At current prices a typical heat pump costs about the same to run as a new gas boiler, but more to fit. How to tell which suits your home, with the real numbers.

Last reviewed
16 November 2026
8
min read
An air source heat pump on a paved patio against the back wall of a red brick semi-detached house
Key takeaways
  • At late 2026 prices, a typical heat pump costs about the same to run as a new boiler.
  • Heat pumps in a government trial ran at a median efficiency of 2.78, below most design figures.
  • A heat pump needs an efficiency of about 3.04 to beat a new gas boiler on unit costs.
  • The Boiler Upgrade Scheme gives Β£7,500 towards a heat pump in England and Wales, as of September 2026.
  • No UK law stops you replacing a gas boiler with a new one in an existing home.
  • Household electricity carries no VAT in Great Britain until July 2027, and the government plans to scrap gas standing charges from 2027, which would change the sums again.

At energy prices for late 2026, a typical heat pump costs about the same to run as a new gas boiler, sometimes a little more and sometimes a little less, and it costs more to fit even after the grant. A heat pump suits a well-insulated home with room for a hot water cylinder and radiators that work at lower temperatures; a new boiler suits a home where those are not in place yet.

This guide compares the two. For the differences between combi, system and conventional boilers, see our boiler buying guide, and for prices, see boiler costs.

Which is cheaper to run?

It comes down to two numbers: the price of each fuel, and how efficiently each system turns it into heat. From 1 October to 31 December 2026, the price cap sets gas at 7.97p per kWh and electricity at 26.32p per kWh, so each unit of electricity costs 3.3 times as much as gas.

A new gas boiler must be at least 92% efficient. A heat pump moves heat from outside air into the home, so it delivers more heat than the electricity it uses. The ratio over a year, its seasonal performance factor, decides whether it wins.

boilers-heat-pump-vs-gas-running-cost

The break-even point is a seasonal performance of about 3.04 on unit costs alone. If you switch completely and have the gas supply removed, you also stop paying the gas standing charge, about Β£110 a year, and the break-even falls to about 2.66.

One date matters. Household electricity has carried no VAT in Great Britain since 1 October 2026, and the zero rate now runs until July 2027. If 5% VAT returns after that at the same underlying price, the median heat pump in the table costs about Β£41 a year more to run.

Updated 16 November 2026: the zero rate on household electricity was due to end on 31 March 2027, but the Autumn Budget extended it until July 2027. The government has also asked Ofgem to remove the standing charge on household gas bills in 2027 or as soon as possible after, moving its cost into the price of each unit of gas. If that goes ahead, removing your gas supply will no longer save a separate standing charge, but each unit of gas a heat pump replaces will cost a little more, so the break-even would shift again. The figures on this page use today's prices. Our post on gas standing charges being scrapped explains who is likely to gain and who could pay more.

Why real heat pumps do better or worse

The design figure is not the bill

A heat pump's quoted efficiency, its SCOP, is a design figure. What you pay depends on its seasonal performance factor in your home. In the government's trial, measured performance was below the design figure in 91.9% of homes, with a median shortfall of 17.9%.

The trial, run by the Energy Systems Catapult for DESNZ, found a median seasonal performance of 2.78 across 428 air source heat pumps, with the middle half of homes between 2.55 and 3.05. It found no significant difference by house type or age.

What made the difference was the water temperature. Systems running at 35Β°C averaged 3.50; at 55Β°C they fell to 2.38, and above 65Β°C to 2.02. Lower temperatures need bigger radiators or underfloor heating, which is why a good heat pump design checks every room.

What does each cost to fit?

A heat pump costs far more to install. The median installed cost of an air source heat pump under the Boiler Upgrade Scheme was Β£12,908 between April and June 2026, before the grant came off.

  • With the Β£7,500 grant: you pay about Β£5,408.
  • Off the gas grid, heated by oil or LPG: the grant rises to Β£9,000 for applications made by 31 March 2027, so about Β£3,908.
  • A replacement gas boiler: the Energy Saving Trust puts a typical replacement at about Β£3,500.

Installing a heat pump also carries 0% VAT until 31 March 2027, then 5%. A new gas boiler is charged at 20%. Our boiler costs page breaks down what a boiler replacement includes.

Is your home ready for a heat pump?

Work through these before asking for heat pump quotes:

  • Insulation: a draughty, poorly insulated home needs hotter water to stay warm, which lowers a heat pump's efficiency. Deal with the loft and walls first.
  • Radiators: some radiators may need upsizing to work at lower temperatures. The installer's room-by-room design should list which.
  • A hot water cylinder: heat pumps usually heat a stored tank, so a combi boiler home needs space for one.
  • Outdoor space: the unit sits outside on a wall or the ground, and in England it must meet a noise limit of 37 decibels at the neighbour's window to count as permitted development.
  • Your plans: the grant needs the old fossil fuel system removed, so a hybrid of heat pump and boiler does not qualify.

If most of these are not in place yet, a new boiler is usually the practical choice for now, and the fabric work can come first.

A worked example: a three-bed semi using 9,500 kWh of gas

Ofgem's typical home uses 9,500 kWh of gas a year, the figure it has used since 1 July 2026. With a new 92% boiler, that buys 8,740 kWh of heat.

  • Gas: 9,500 kWh Γ— 7.97p = Β£757 a year, plus the gas standing charge of about Β£110.
  • Median heat pump (2.78): 8,740 Γ· 2.78 = 3,144 kWh of electricity Γ— 26.32p = Β£827 a year.
  • Running costs: Β£70 a year more than gas on units alone, or Β£38 a year less if the gas supply is removed, for as long as gas bills carry a standing charge.
  • Upfront: about Β£5,408 for the heat pump after the grant, against about Β£3,500 for a boiler, so Β£1,908 more.

At the median, the running cost saving never repays the extra upfront cost. At the upper quartile (3.05), the saving with the gas removed is about Β£111 a year, which repays the Β£1,908 in about 17 years. Heat pump electricity tariffs can change this, but they are commercial offers with no official figures, so they are not modelled here.

What are the rules on gas boilers?

As of September 2026, no law in any UK nation stops you replacing a gas boiler with a new one in an existing home. The rules that do exist are about new homes and efficiency:

  • New homes in Scotland: gas and oil boilers cannot be used as the main heating in new builds under the New Build Heat Standard.
  • New homes in England: the Future Homes Standard applies from 24 March 2027.
  • Replacement boilers everywhere in Great Britain: a new gas boiler must be at least 92% efficient.
  • Scotland's plans to end polluting heating by 2045 exist only as a draft bill.

The government has said any role for hydrogen in home heating would come later and "likely be limited", so treat a "hydrogen-ready" label as a feature, not a plan.

Questions to ask before you choose

  • What heat loss did you calculate for each room, and which radiators need changing?
  • What seasonal performance do you expect, at what water temperature, and how did you work it out?
  • Where will the unit and the cylinder go, and does the unit meet the noise rules?
  • For a boiler: what size do I need, and which controls will you fit to meet the rules?
  • What does each quote include, from pipework and radiators to removing the old system?

Watch out for these

  • Being asked to pay the grant amount. The Boiler Upgrade Scheme grant comes off your bill. By law the installer must not ask you to pay the discounted amount.
  • Running cost promises with no working. Ask how the estimate was made, and at what performance figure.
  • "Gas boilers are being banned" sales pitches. There is no ban on replacing a boiler in an existing home.
  • More than one application. Ofgem accepts your consent for a single grant application only, so agree which installer will apply before you give it.

How it differs across the UK

  • England and Wales: the Boiler Upgrade Scheme covers heat pumps and biomass boilers, never gas, oil or LPG boilers.
  • Scotland: Home Energy Scotland offers a heat pump grant of up to Β£7,500, with more in rural and island areas, as of September 2026.
  • Northern Ireland: there is no Boiler Upgrade Scheme; heat pump support runs through NISEP schemes.
  • Energy prices: the price cap and the zero rate of VAT on electricity apply in Great Britain; Northern Ireland electricity stays at 5% VAT.
  • Planning: England and Wales allow most air source heat pumps under permitted development subject to limits; Scotland limits size and position, especially in conservation areas; Northern Ireland requires at least a metre to the boundary.

Where to go next

Staying with gas? Get a new boiler quote

If a new boiler is the right choice for your home, get a free, no-obligation quote from a Gas Safe registered engineer, with the boiler sized to your home and the controls the rules require.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Compare free quotes

Free and no obligation. We only share your details with the installers we match you with.

Common questions

Can a heat pump work with my existing radiators?

Sometimes. It depends on how much heat each room loses and how big the radiators are. The installer's room-by-room design shows which, if any, need upsizing.

Do heat pumps work in old houses?

They can. The government trial found no significant difference in performance by house type or age. Insulation and radiator size matter more than the year the house was built.

Does a heat pump need a hot water cylinder?

Usually, yes. Most heat pumps heat a stored tank of water rather than heating it on demand like a combi boiler, so you need space for a cylinder.

How loud is a heat pump?

In England, to count as permitted development, a heat pump must meet a noise limit of 37 decibels at the nearest neighbour's window, measured to the MCS standard.

Are gas boilers being banned?

Not for existing homes, as of September 2026. New homes in Scotland cannot use them as the main heating, and England's new-build rules change on 24 March 2027.

Staying with gas? Get a new boiler quote

If a new boiler is the right choice for your home, get a free, no-obligation quote from a Gas Safe registered engineer, with the boiler sized to your home and the controls the rules require.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Compare free quotes

Free and no obligation. We only share your details with the installers we match you with.

What each system costs to run

Yearly fuel cost for a home that uses 9,500 kWh of gas, at the prices in force from October to December 2026.

boilers-heat-pump-vs-gas-running-cost
2
System Efficiency Energy bought a year Fuel cost a year Against gas Against gas, supply removed New gas boiler 92% 9,500 kWh gas Β£757 None None Heat pump, lower quartile 2.55 3,427 kWh electricity Β£902 Β£145 more Β£37 more Heat pump, median 2.78 3,144 kWh electricity Β£827 Β£70 more Β£38 less Heat pump, upper quartile 3.05 2,866 kWh electricity Β£754 Β£3 less Β£111 less
Great Britain price cap averages for direct debit, October to December 2026: gas 7.97p per kWh, electricity 26.32p per kWh. Heat pump performance from a government trial.
Ofgem price cap and typical consumption values (2026); Energy Systems Catapult for DESNZ, Electrification of Heat trial (2024); Approved Document L. Checked September 2026.

The last column counts the gas standing charge of 29.68p a day, about Β£110 a year, that you stop paying if the gas supply is removed altogether. Tariffs designed for heat pumps are not modelled, because they are commercial offers with no official figures.

Compare free quotes

From vetted, accredited installers near you. Free, and no obligation.

Get free quotes
Back to top
Free, no obligation

See what a new boiler would cost

Enter your postcode and we will match you with Gas Safe registered engineers for free, no-obligation quotes.

Loading your quote form

We pass your details to one vetted local installer, so they can contact you with a quote. Our privacy policy explains how we use your data.

One short form Β· Vetted, certified installers Β· Compare quotes with no obligation